The traditional way of testing etching and corrosion is to repeat a number of wash cycles and thereafter visually inspect the object for etching effects. Sometimes, as many as 70 wash cycles may be required to detect and evaluate the etching. This is both costly and time-consuming but there are faster ways. Here we present a method that will help you assess the etching effects in one single wash cycle and in less than an hour.
The experimental setup for a 1h assessment of etching effects
QSense® technology is a method that can monitor surface etching with high resolution in a time-resolved manner. Thanks to the nanoscale sensitivity of this technology, removal of surface material can be detected and quantified in a single wash cycle.
Comparison of the etching properties of two commercial detergents on glass
As an example, let us look at an assessment of the etching of two commercial detergents. Using a fully automated QSense instrument, the etching properties of detergent A and detergent B on soda lime were evaluated. Two different temperatures, 25 and 40°C, were tested and Swedish tap was used as a control. The 50-minute long wash program, used in the test, consisted of a 30-minute wash step and a 20-minute rinse step where Swedish tap water was used.
After the test, the etch rate during the detergent exposure was extracted, and the average surface removal was calculated as thickness removed per hour measured in nanometers.
Detergent A showed higher etching than detergent B
The results, Fig. 1., show that the etching was both detergent and temperature dependent. Detergent A showed higher etching than detergent B at both temperatures and the etching increased with the temperature for both detergents. The control measurement showed no surface removal at neither 25 °C nor 40 °C.
Figure 1. Etching results for two commercial detergents, detergent A and detergent B, evaluated at two different temperatures, 25°C and 40°C, using QSense technology
Etching assessments can be very time-consuming, and they often involve an element of subjective nature, for example, grading by visual inspection. QSense technology offers both fast and objective quantification of etching effects. The method enables single point etching data, for a given surface and temperature, to be collected within one hour.
Download the guide to learn more about the procedure for evaluation of detergent etching properties using QSense technology.
When, Nouryon (former AkzoNobel speciality chemicals), launched a new surfactant with a good dermatological profile, they wanted to prove superior performance vs competitive benchmarks. As the current test methods were not sensitive enough, they turned to an analysis using QSense cleaning profile.
Throughout the cleaning product life cycle, ranking of performance is an important type of assessment. It can be quite time-consuming, but with the right approach, it is possible to evaluate and rank the product performance in less than one hour. Here we tell you how.
Eva Ekerot is the Senior Commercial Portfolio Manager for QSense. She has a background managing numerous product portfolios within the medical technology and analytical instrument industries. She is devoted to user driven development of high tech products. More user friendly technology is accessible to more people!